tisdag 30 november 2010

the REVIEW of the REVIEWS of SKIN

Dennis Harvey's rating: "Design contributions are well-turned, tech aspects solidly pro."
The article from 'Variety' is considered, by me, as a retelling of the film rather than a review. Dennis Harvey offers scarce personal views. Apart from the last paragraph, where he mentions one sentence for each main character, there seems to be no comments within the review.

Roger Ebert's Rating: ****
Roger Ebert's four star review based on personal accounts is a well written article with few plot spoilers.

Reviewer's Rating: C+
Article three is probably the least pre-constructed article i have ever read. The anonymous critic is extremely narrow-minded. I recon there is no room in the spotlight for such a poor review concentrated on pointing out the scarcely occurring flaws of the film.

mlfaron.blogspot.com
Aron's Rating: A satisfying discussion-inducing film
Asking me for an opinion would lead to a character analysis and a discussion regarding apartheid. I think this is exactly what the director meant for when creating this artistic film adaption of Sandra Liang's life.

Inga kommentarer:

Skicka en kommentar